What is the difference between an ETF and a mutual fund?
By Ghost Man Trades · Last reviewed · Education only, not advice
ETFs and mutual funds in plain English
Both are funds: you buy shares, the fund uses everyone's money to hold a basket of stocks, bonds or other assets, and you own a slice of the whole basket. One share of an S&P 500 fund gives you a small piece of 500 companies. The differences are mostly about how you trade them and how they are taxed.
- Mutual fund: you buy shares from the fund (directly or through a broker) and sell them back to the fund. Orders fill at the net asset value (NAV), the value of the holdings per share, typically calculated at the end of each business day. Place an order at 11 AM and you get that evening's price.
- ETF (exchange-traded fund): you buy and sell shares with other investors on a stock exchange, at whatever the market price is during the day, just like a stock. The price usually stays close to NAV but can trade at a small premium or discount.
What to compare
- Expense ratio: the yearly fee as a percentage of your investment.
- Trading: ETFs trade all day and work with limit orders; mutual funds trade once a day at NAV.
- Taxes: in taxable accounts, ETFs often distribute fewer capital gains.
- Minimums and automation: some mutual funds have investment minimums, while many are easy to set up for automatic monthly purchases.
Example (hypothetical numbers).
- You invest $10,000 in each of two funds tracking the same index. Fund A charges 0.03% a year; Fund B charges 0.75%.
- Yearly cost: $10,000 × 0.03% = $3 versus $10,000 × 0.75% = $75.
- Over 20 years on a growing balance, that $72-a-year difference compounds into a much larger gap, all for owning the same index.
- Premium example: an ETF's NAV is $100.00 but it trades at $100.20. Buying there means paying a 0.2% premium ($0.20 ÷ $100) over the value of its holdings.
Common mistakes
- Comparing on structure alone. A cheap mutual fund beats an expensive ETF. Check the actual costs.
- Trading ETFs too much. Intraday trading is possible, not required. Frequent trading adds costs and taxes.
- Market orders on thin ETFs. Small ETFs can have wide spreads, especially near the open.
- Ignoring what's inside. Two "technology" funds can hold very different stocks. Read the holdings.
- Assuming a fund means no risk. A fund of 500 stocks is diversified across companies, not protected from a market decline.
How Ghost Man uses this
The Ghost Report focuses on individual stocks, but ETFs show up in two places. The sector rotation table compares the 11 SPDR sector ETFs with SPY, the S&P 500 ETF. And on the metals pages, where we compare Ghost Man signals with simply holding, gold and silver ETFs such as GLD and SLV give cleaner price histories than futures, which have contract-roll gaps. For metals, the honest result so far is that simply holding did better than following the signals on most instruments.
Mutual funds can't be traded on our signals: there is no intraday price or next-open fill, only end-of-day NAV.
Related terms
- Diversification and correlation · What are diversification and correlation in investing?
- Dollar-cost averaging · What is dollar-cost averaging?
- Market order vs limit order · What is the difference between a market order and a limit order?
- Sector rotation · What is sector rotation, and what are the 11 stock market sectors?
- Relative strength vs the S&P 500 · What is relative strength compared with the S&P 500?
Learn it step by step in Swing School
Frequently asked questions
Are ETFs cheaper than mutual funds?
Often, but not always. Many index ETFs have very low expense ratios, but so do many index mutual funds. Compare the expense ratio, any sales loads and trading costs for the specific funds.
Are ETFs more tax-efficient?
In taxable accounts, ETFs often make fewer capital gains distributions than mutual funds, which can mean lower taxes. In tax-advantaged accounts such as IRAs, the difference doesn't matter.
Can an ETF trade at a different price from its holdings?
Yes. Its market price can be at a premium or discount to its NAV. For large, liquid ETFs the gap is usually small, but it can widen in stressed markets or for thinly traded funds.
Is an index fund an ETF or a mutual fund?
Either. Index fund describes the strategy of tracking an index. Index funds come in both mutual fund and ETF form.
Sources
We check every definition and formula against these sources. Our own rules come from the Ghost Man scan code that runs this site.
- Investor.gov: Investor Bulletin, Characteristics of Mutual Funds and Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs)
- SEC: Mutual Funds and Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs), A Guide for Investors